My friend Steve posted a comment on my last post that I thought was deserving of a post all to itself. He said:
Joe,
If you have a good idea, you shouldn’t put it up on your website, man. Someone is gonna’ steal it. Take your flower idea and hoard it, man. Because, I’m gonna’ be honest with you, Victorian women using flowers to fight with in that punk setting is awesome. And you need to protect your kids, dude.
I can understand why people would be wary of sharing their best story ideas in a public place. For a long time, that was my philosophy as well: that good ideas should be hoarded and protected, lest anyone should “steal” them and run away with all the credit.
However, I know what I’m doing. My perspectives have changed, and I have several reasons for posting my story ideas up here publicly. Here are a few of them:
1) Ideas are cheap.
There are a ton of really good story ideas floating around in the sf/f publishing world. In English 318, Brandon Sanderson said that any given editor sees dozens of fascinating, imaginative, stupendous ideas in any given day. The thing that gets you the contract, though, is the quality of your writing. There are just so many amazing story ideas out there that even the most amazing ideas are relatively common.
2) Everyone has a different take on the same idea.
Two authors, writing essentially the same story, will come at it so differently that both books will be unique. Heinlein’s take on space travel is very different from Frank Herbert’s or Arthur C. Clarke’s, and Haldeman’s take on galactic war and colonization is radically different from Scalzi’s. Trantor is not Coruscanth, and Arrakis is not Tatooine.
All these story elements, though based on similar ideas, differ radically from each other because each author had a different take on things. When we write fiction, we bring all our personal beliefs, values, experiences, and perspectives to the story, whether consciously or subconsciously. It’s unavoidable. And since all of us are unique and different, so long as we’re honest in our writing our stories are going to reflect that uniqueness.
I’m not afraid of someone “stealing” my ideas because I know that my approach is different enough that my stories (so long as they’re honest) will be very different.
3) It takes several ideas, combined in a unique way, to make a full novel.
I used to think that you could write a novel based off of two or three really good ideas. Maybe that’s why I never finished anything. I’ve learned over the last year that, in fact, it takes somewhere around fifteen or twenty ideas, minimum, to come up with a good story. And that’s just for starters. Once you sit down and start writing it, new ideas erupt as the story progresses, and you find yourself taking things in unplanned directions. Adjusting your plans and integrating the new ideas with the old ones is part of good writing.
Brandon Sanderson said this in English 318, and I believe it: a novel is not found in the ideas by themselves, it’s found in the synergy that happens as you combine them together. As ingredients, your ideas may be powerful by themselves, but when you combine them together, the end result is much more powerful than the mere sum of them all. It’s all in how the ideas intermix.
4) Ideas grow and develop when you bounce them off of other people.
I do not believe that story ideas are static. They are not like Lego blocks that you stack together to make a construct. They are dynamic–they change and grow over time, like plants in a garden. If you take a plant and hide it in a closet, it will die. Similarly, I believe that if you “hoard” your story ideas, showing them to nobody and putting off writing them until you can write the best novel possible, those ideas will become weaker.
I tried to hoard one of my story ideas a few years ago, thinking that it was the best idea I’d ever come up with and that I needed to wait until I was experienced enough to include it in my magnus opus. Now, the idea doesn’t even interest me that much. I’ve grown, but the idea hasn’t, and I’ve moved on to other things.
My goal in sharing my story ideas here on this blog is to bounce them off of other creative minds and start a discussion. From that discussion, I think that my ideas will grow and become stronger. Other people often see things that I miss, and their take on things can really spark my imagination and help me to take my ideas to a new level. Discussing my ideas, not hoarding them, is what I need.
5) It’s easier to lose a notebook than it is to lose data stored on your website.
This last idea is purely practical. I keep a notebook with me at all times and scribble down story ideas in it as they come to me. Over the summer, I lost a notebook that I’d been keeping for several months. It had maybe thirty or forty story ideas in it, and now those are lost. From that, I learned the importance of keeping a backup. This website, in a way, is my backup.
So those are the main reasons why I’ve decided to blog about my story ideas and make them public. If my story ideas inspire you, then by all means go ahead and run with them. We live in an open source world, and besides, your take on the idea is still going to be very different from mine. And if you have any thoughts to share, please do! I welcome comments, especially for these posts on my story ideas. My goal is to bounce ideas off of you as the reader, because interaction is one of the things that makes blogging so useful.
