They really are. Yesterday while I was biking up to campus, a young woman (probably a college freshman) pulled out of a driveway to make a right turn and failed to look both ways before turning. As a result, she struck my bike, bending my rim and forcing me to replace it.
I got her name and phone number, spent about an hour (and $54) fixing the thing, and gave her a call. She didn’t answer any of my calls that day, but she called up the next morning to tell me that she’d talked with a policeman, that I was at fault, and that therefore she wasn’t going to pay me anything.
Of course I was frustrated at all of this, seeing as 1) I was a PEDESTRIAN on the SIDEWALK, and therefore not at fault, and 2) she had failed to look both ways before turning into traffic. What if I hadn’t braked? What if she’d hit me full on? I could have gotten seriously hurt due to her negligence!
So I told her “look, whether you pay me or not, will you promise me to look both ways before you enter traffic?” And her response–I kid you not–was “have you taken a defensive driving course? If you had, you would know that drivers making a right turn aren’t required to look right before entering traffic.”
WTF. Seriously?
Apart from the $54, which I figured she wasn’t going to pay for (jerk), this last comment profoundly bothered me. I only came out of this with a damaged bike–what if the next guy isn’t so lucky? So I sent her the following text:
As a driver, it is your responsibility to look both ways before turning. I don’t want you to injure the next guy.
To which she replied with the following:
As a cyclist, it is your responsibility to be on the correct side of the road and to give the right-of-way to who it belongs to. This mishap happened because of your own wrong doing- not mine. I’m choosing to look past the damage you’ve done to my car, which I could very easily require you to pay for (and it would cost much more than your rim that was “damaged” because you a)were on the wrong side of the road and b)failed to yield the right-of-way. That’s my way of being kind to a disrespectful person such as yourself (you hung up on me in mid-sentence). There is no reason to call or text message me anymore because the issue is over with. Any other text messages or calls I receive from will be considered harassment, and I will file charges against you.
A few things:
- As a pedestrian, the right-of-way was mine–that was what the Provo police told me when I called them today;
- While I shared some of the blame for riding on the wrong side of the road, she violated the law by failing to yield the right of way when crossing from private property onto a public street (again, taken from the officer I spoke with);
- I seriously doubt her car received any more damage than a few scratches, whereas I have the bent rim to prove that the “damages” to my bike were very real;
- I hung up on her mid-sentence because she kept pushing me to admit that I was at fault and that she was not in the wrong–instead of calling to apologize and work things out, she called to seek validation for shafting me.
What a jerk. She’s lucky I’m not taking this to her insurance company and trying to resolve it with them. While I’m sure that she fully deserves the rate hike and the stain on her record, I just don’t want to deal with the hassle.
The next time this happens, though (and I’m sure it will, because Utah drivers act as if pedestrians don’t exist), I’m going to call the police and resolve the issue with the law. I no longer trust Utahans to be honest and forthright in settling issues like this civilly. If you’re on the road and they can screw you, believe me, they will.
I agree, what an infuriating hassle and danger!
The photo looks like your sister. Or is it the driver? Certainly not both!
Forget the body swapping idea… edges on porn.
And the #1 reason I looked up your sci-fi blog this a.m.: I read plot twists and turns worthy of sci-fi, though it was history at one time and place, in Ether 7.
She sounds like an incredible jerk. Sorry you have to deal with her.
At the same time, I wouldn’t generalize to “Utah” drivers. I’ve been all over the country, and there’s nothing inherently bad about Utah drivers. I visited California a couple weeks ago, and I saw a much higher incident rate of “bad driving” than I’ve ever seen in Utah.
Not to mention that many of the college students you’ll find in Provo aren’t from Utah. But it makes me curious as to where she’s actually from–what’s the prefix on her cellphone? Is it an 801 number?
Joe–
Sorry to hear about the accident. When stuff like this happens, it’s important to follow through with all of the paperwork as soon as possible (insurance, police report, etc.). Covering all of your bases at the beginning gives you more options as the process plays out.
Were you on the sidewalk or in the road? Oftentimes you’re safer riding on the side of the road than on the sidewalk–drivers are not used to anticipating something on the sidewalk moving as quickly as a bike.
I’m sure you did this already, but have the bike mechanic go over your bike thoroughly to make sure that nothing else is out of alignment.
In interactions with drivers, do your best to be civil and at the same time not cede any of your rights to the driver, even though it can be frustrating at times.
-Technically- you’re only a pedestrian if you’re on foot. Just saying.
Yeah, she doesn’t have to look right when entering traffic, but she -does- when driving her car over the sidewalk. Even if I were in her position and thought none of it was my fault, the decent thing to do is at least -apologize-, you know? Had it been me, I may have paid the damages merely out of guilt, because yeah, I was part of an accident. (Looking at both arguments, it may have been a 50/50 fault, but who knows, I wasn’t there.)
What damage did she get to her car?
ANYWAY, I’m glad you didn’t get run over–fixing a broken leg is more of a pain than a broken bike.
Uh, yeah Utah driver’s? Try coming to Houston. It’s about 100% worse. I get cut off multiple times everyday, and people are always changing lines without signaling. It is soooooo BAD.
Still, sounds like this lady was a jerk. You should always always always call the police when you get in a accident.